Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Wendy's avatar

Great job this week, Blake!

Another chance for the Mets to demystify the Braves. Let’s Go Mets!

Expand full comment
Jimmy P's avatar

Good job on the podcast. I respect what you do, the calm tone, the conversation and the length. But I find them very hard to listen to, personally, which is more about me that you.

Curiously, while I find that I'm often in agreement with the written version of Peter here, I couldn't agree with you, Peter, on any of the three players discussed today. The idea that Bader is "doing well" and should be pissed off about playing time. You guys quote the BA and ignore every other offensive measure. Are you sincerely arguing that he should be playing more? Yes, a .280 BA but little else in 100 ABs. He's being used correctly, perhaps too much. His SLG is .340, OPS is .654. Not good. Taylor in 73 ABs has twice the the HR, RBI, XBH, SLG at .425 and OPS at .737. He's also a good glove. Stewart in only 65 ABs has 4 HR, 16 RBI (Bader is 1 & 7). But you come out in support of Bader playing more? The whiner is not doing well and probably needs slightly less playing time. What he's doing is fairly consistent with who he's been historically. The only strange thing is he got $10 million.

I personally think it's obvious that the Mets would have been insane to extend Pete over the winter, since it would have essentially caved to his wildly unrealistic demands (based on Boras comments). When we look at terrible contracts in the recent past -- say, um, McCann (4 years!) and Narvaez -- the question that comes up for me is always: Who did they think they were bidding against? Let's allow Pete to go to market. As you said, yes, it only takes one crazy team to outbid us. But you seem to be arguing for the Mets to be that crazy team. I want to keep Pete. I do, and agree with you there. But length of contract is hugely important and worth fighting for. It's not just a business decision, it's also a baseball decision, and the two are intertwined.

The one business issue that does merit discussion, I think, is the fact that tickets sales are waaaaay down. Season tickets down 30%, I've heard. The place is empty. I gather that Cohen was willing to absorb this hit, for now. A terrible season in 23 and a quiet winter and lowered expectations will do that. But I don't think they can repeat that. Somehow they need to thread the needle, make the right baseball decision on Pete while still recognizing his value as a "star." Overpay on AAV and stand strong on length.

Lastly, you can defend McNeil until you are blue in the face. He just wants to golf. It will be a good day when the Mets have the assets where they can move on from Jeff. As for now, they don't. The game has changed and speed matters and teams can only get that from 5 positions. Jeff has become a weird "neither/nor" hybrid who lacks pop & speed. His swing is a mess. He offers positional flexibility and that's useful in a utility player. At the same time, there are no options right now so he has time to change my mind. He came into camp with an "overuse" golf injury and I'm just not impressed with any of it.

BTW, the Braves punted on Guillorme and signed Zach Short. That's TWO major league teams who have decided that Short is better, more useful, than Guillorme. Of course, when Guillorme went from the Braves to the Angels, I'm sure he thought: "Now this is more like it!"

He's in the right place.

But he should keep his passport updated.

Can they trade one of these "depth" pitchers? A gamble, for sure.

Expand full comment
37 more comments...

No posts