Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Lee B.'s avatar

I am gonna remind you Jeffrey that these games, and those homers, don't count. With respect to Mr. Mauricio who may or may not read this and take it personally - great Meme work, sir - his value to the club is down and continues to decrease. He is 90 on Fangraph's top 100. He's 56 on ESPN and 87 on Athletic. He's off Baseball America's top 100. He's off MLB's top 100 and was replaced by Ramirez. He's high on the Network lists b/c McDaniel and Law continue to excuse his bad strike zone, awkward body development, and defense at short or third or left field, along with multiple seasons of poor metrics for age. I no longer buy the age rationale. There's too much data on him.

The only value Mauricio has is trade bait - especially now his Guardian Angel Sandy is gone and can't block any trade that includes him in it, or even in the conversation. Mauricio has been blocked at MLB level for multiple years (even before Lindor) at SS, and he's been blocked in OF and 3B when attempting to change positions by MLB FAs or better home grown bench players or better performing prospects like Baty and Ramirez. Mauricio did miss a year of baseball games in 2020, but NOT development because he was an alternate site player. He's made the AFL a couple years in a row. His fall from grace as a top 15 on the top 100 MLB prospects and from #1 down the top 30 Mets prospect lists since 2020, 2021 has been minimally discussed given the surprise, upside and MLB promotion of Vientos and Alvarez who all got cups of coffee and hit homers in the majors last year.

Mauricio has to go. I understand and agree with Cohen and Eppler that a developed, consistent farm system is the ideal path to sustainability. The only value keeping Mauricio has is to collectively score higher as a farm system on ratings. He has no growth potential with the Mets. Yes, he's a good international signing. Yes he bolsters our overall status, but hey, why not trade him when he still has value to replenish the farm and dump a salary like Ruf's? Do it now if we're not getting rid of Ruf yet. If the Mets want to have a better system, don't we need to replenish the depth we forfeited by drafting 'random cheap college senior with no analytical benefits' rounds 3-15 or 3-22 under Alderson and BVW for the last 12 years?

Expand full comment
Kevin Johnson's avatar

Fun one. I see your point about Ronnie…but other guys aren’t doing what you (rightfully) say would be harder against MLB arms. There have been some pretty amazing bad-ball hitters over the years. Intriguing to see where this goes. It would be fun to hear how experts who see what you see evaluate his ongoing efforts to deal with the pitch selection/strikeout syndrome.

Loved Hartwig nugget. I love the guys who have fascinating off-field stories. As a 10 year old in 1969 I heard about Dr. Ron Taylor, a Met relief pitcher who got his medical degree along the way. As Consul General in Toronto I later met him while he was team doctor for the Jays. He had been a fireballing starter who morphed into a tricky reliever. More interestingly, his big arm supported a huge brain. He studied medicine AFTER an engineering degree didn’t convince him. Makes you wonder about God’s fairness: big league arm, engineer, doctor. AND he was more humble and gracious than most folks with any 3 of these accomplishments. Gotta luv it.

Expand full comment
25 more comments...

No posts